GEORGE GERSCHWINN –
IRA GERSCHWINN – PORGY AND BESS – 1935-1959 - DVD
The story is entirely enclosed in a black community that lives on the
coast of South Carolina
next to a fishing harbor. They are fishermen and they till some land for cotton.
They live in some kind of a fort that is closed by a metal and monumental gate
and that is entirely turned inward onto its own courtyard. The only outside
people are the police that comes when a crime is discovered and that is only to
make a token arrest since they never get any testimony about who committed the
crime. There will be two murders in the “fort”. The other visitors are
peddlers. The strawberry lady, the honey man or the crab man do not represent a
danger in any way. But the drug peddler known as Sporting Life is another can
of worms. He is dangerous and his role will be dramatic in the story.
The story is simple. A woman who is more or less an easy woman is the
unmarried woman of a violent man. They are Bess and Crown. She provides her man
with the money he needs to buy alcohol and drugs and to gamble. She is entirely
mesmerized and dominated by the drug, Happy Dust, and her man. The drama starts
with Crown killing another man, Robbins. He runs. The cops want to arrest some
bystander, Peter, but he will be eventually released after some time in prison.
The main witness that testifies no one has seen anything is a cripple and
beggar, Porgy. He appears as being the one who defends the waterproof character
of the community. Do not deal with the white police. He is also the one who is
going to take care of Bess, left behind by Crown who is on the run.
The rest is the story of the fight of this woman between two men, Porgy
and Crown, a battle that is lost from the very start but not by the fault of
anyone in the community but because of the outside “invaders” the police and
the drug peddler are.
The drug peddler has it right when he says that two men for one woman
always end up with one man dead and the other in prison, and the woman having
no one at all. Porgy kills Crown, is arrested with no testimony against him but
under the pretext that he is supposed to identify Crown’s dead body, which he
refuses to do, even when in front of the body. He is sent to prison for
contempt of court. Hence Bess ends up alone, an easy prey to Sportin’ Life who
manages her so that she goes back to drugs and then goes away with him to New York. When Porgy
comes back with presents for everyone, since he played dice in prison and made
a little fortune, the community is friendly with him but does not want to tell
him where Bess is. He finally gets it out of them and he decides to drop his
two crutches and go to New York
after Bess.
That kind of rivalry between the protector of an easy woman and someone
who falls in love with her is not so uncommon, even in the opera world. The new
element is the fact that the man ho falls in love with the woman is a cripple
and the protector turns criminal. The rivalry between two men for one woman is
not uncommon in all spheres of literature and music and the fact that one kills
the other is banal, except that here it is the cripple who kills the super
strong and powerful protector. The end is purely opportunistic. The woman is
totally unable to live without the authority of a man: she is helpless without
a man and she finds herself alone. She cannot choose the community as a
substitute or at least she cannot resist the suggestion from a third man, the
drug peddler who proposes her to go back to easy life in the big city up north.
But this opera is a lot more interesting than this dramatic love affair
and this surprisingly effective love quartet, one woman and three men. As long
as the black community lives closed up on itself it can survive more or less
decently though poor but proud of what they can make on the very edge of the
white society outside, the society of the buckras. When you get out of this
cocoon, you run all kinds of dangers: fishermen are killed by hurricanes when
they go fishing. Women are exploited into selling themselves to anyone, into
drug addiction and even slavery of some kind when they get out and follow a man
out of their community. And it is from outside that the drug peddler comes to
bring into the community what may destroy that community. And yet this
community is totally pervaded by gambling with dice, alcoholism with whisky and
moonshine alcohol, and even common brutality among the members. What saves them
is their solidarity in front of the outside white society. They even have a
fringe of black exploiters like the undertaker, the divorce dealer, the drug
peddler and some others that ransom their own black community for any mostly
illegal reason.
Solidarity cannot do anything against that kind of easy exploitation.
The opera was composed in 1935 and represented a revolution in itself.
The action concerned a black community that was depicted as containing normal
human feelings and passions and that was under the perversion imposed onto them
by the white society outside that both victimized the community with systematic
suspicion and made that community close up onto itself into some autarchic
functioning that made them accept to be exploited by some black crooks and
accept the violence of some of their members even when it became criminal. In
other words their minds are totally colonized, under the domination from an
outside, surrounding and seen and felt as superior group that dominates them.
In 1935 there was yet no way out of this colonized situation except hard work
to make a better living in that system but that did not change it, no matter
whether they were fishing or growing cotton. Their lot was to be fishermen or
sharecroppers. We were at the time still a long way from the education and then
civil rights transformation, the main two ways for these communities to open up
on the world, for the individuals in these communities to find their way up in
society by conquering an equal, or at least as equal as possible position in
the surrounding white society. But this opera showed that the situation was
becoming highly explosive inside and in the relations with the outside world.
It could not last very long indeed because presents, beautiful dresses, new
hats were wanted and there would come a time when these people would say: we
want them and they will finally do what they can to get them without selling
their bodies, drugs or fake divorces, not to speak of coffins and funerals.
And yet the composer is not black which means the Blacks are not in
1935, though they are some of the greatest musicians in America already
at the time, accepted on Broadway yet. It will take a long time before the
Blacks are accepted as equal in showbiz as composers, authors and artists. But
this quasi-all-black opera is a very important precursor of “Guess who’s coming
to dinner” that was only to come out in 1967, thirty two years and one World
War later.
But the music is surprisingly modern and avant-garde for its time and
even today. It is both melodious with some sentences coming back both with
words and notes, but also disruptive of standard harmony and melody, working on
slight variations from major to minor tones, and working tremendously on half
tones and other intervals that are often taken downward when we expect upward
movements or vice versa. It is not jazz but it integrates some of the innovations
of jazz in the music and particularly the polyrhythmic aspect of African and
African-American music by playing on the chorus as opposed to the leading
voice, or on some more distant rhythm that has its autonomy behind the voice,
on on gospel technique of a chorus calling for attention every so often in the
rhetoric of some songs and introducing a different tempo articulated on the
main tempo. Hallelujah! We are like entering a musical forest in which each
tree is revealing the whole forest and all the other trees of it.
Dr Jacques COULARDEAU
SHORTER VERSION
The story is entirely enclosed in a black community that lives on the
coast of South Carolina
next to a fishing harbour. They are fishermen and they till some land for
cotton. They live in some kind of a fort that is closed by a metal and
monumental gate and that is entirely turned inward onto its own courtyard. The
only outside people are the police that comes when a crime is discovered and
that is only to make a token arrest since they never get any testimony about
who committed the crime. There will be two murders in the “fort”. The other
visitors are peddlers. The strawberry lady, the honey man or the crab man do
not represent a danger in any way. But the drug peddler known as Sportin’ Life
is another can of worms. He is dangerous and his role will be dramatic in the
story.
The drug peddler has it right when he says that two men for one woman
always end up with one man dead and the other in prison, and the woman having
no one at all. Porgy kills Crown, is arrested with no testimony against him but
under the pretext that he is supposed to identify Crown’s dead body, which he
refuses to do, even when in front of the body. He is sent to prison for
contempt of court. Hence Bess ends up alone, an easy prey to Sportin’ Life who
manages her so that she goes back to drugs and then goes away with him to New York. When Porgy
comes back with presents for everyone, since he played dice in prison and made
a little fortune, the community is friendly with him but does not want to tell
him where Bess is. He finally gets it out of them and he decides to drop his
two crutches and go to New York
after Bess.
But this opera is a lot more interesting than this dramatic love affair
and this surprisingly effective love quartet, one woman and three men. As long
as the black community lives closed up on itself it can survive more or less
decently though poor but proud of what they can make on the very edge of the
white society outside, the society of the buckras. When you get out of this
cocoon, you run all kinds of dangers: fishermen are killed by hurricanes when
they go fishing. Women are exploited into selling themselves to anyone, into
drug addiction and even slavery of some kind when they get out and follow a man
out of their community. And it is from outside that the drug peddler comes to
bring into the community what may destroy that community. And yet this
community is totally pervaded by gambling with dice, alcoholism with whisky and
moonshine alcohol, and even common brutality among the members. What saves them
is their solidarity in front of the outside white society. They even have a
fringe of black exploiters like the undertaker, the divorce dealer, the drug
peddler and some others that ransom their own black community for any mostly
illegal reason.
Solidarity cannot do anything against that kind of easy exploitation.
The opera was composed in 1935 and represented a revolution in itself.
The action concerned a black community that was depicted as containing normal
human feelings and passions and that was under the perversion imposed onto them
by the white society outside that both victimized the community with systematic
suspicion and made that community close up onto itself into some autarchic
functioning that made them accept to be exploited by some black crooks and
accept the violence of some of their members even when it became criminal. In
other words their minds are totally colonized, under the domination from an
outside, surrounding and seen and felt as superior group that dominates them.
In 1935 there was yet no way out of this colonized situation except hard work
to make a better living in that system but that did not change it, no matter
whether they were fishing or growing cotton. Their lot was to be fishermen or
sharecroppers. We were at the time still a long way from the education and then
civil rights transformation, the main two ways for these communities to open up
on the world, for the individuals in these communities to find their way up in society
by conquering an equal, or at least as equal as possible position in the
surrounding white society. But this opera showed that the situation was
becoming highly explosive inside and in the relations with the outside world.
It could not last very long indeed because presents, beautiful dresses, new
hats were wanted and there would come a time when these people would say: we
want them and they will finally do what they can to get them without selling
their bodies, drugs or fake divorces, not to speak of coffins and funerals.
And yet the composer is not black which means the Blacks are not in
1935, though they are some of the greatest musicians in America already
at the time, accepted on Broadway yet. It will take a long time before the
Blacks are accepted as equal in showbiz as composers, authors and artists. But
this quasi-all-black opera is a very important precursor of “Guess who’s coming
to dinner” that was only to come out in 1967, thirty two years and one World
War later.
Dr Jacques COULARDEAU
GEORGE GERSCHWINN –
IRA GERSCHWINN – PORGY AND BESS – 1935-1959 – SIMON RATTLE – CD
The first act of this opera sets up the drama in a fully self-contained
Black community working as fishermen for some and cotton sharecroppers for the
rest. We are inside their living quarters that are devised as a fort with all
rooms opening only onto the inside yard where everything happens. The community
is shown as pretty idle though we understand we are on Saturday night and the
activities are alcohol, a crap game, drugs (happy dust) and women. The drug
dealer is Sporting Life. This situational composition leads to Robbins playing
against Crown. Robbins is a plain member of the community, married to Serena,
whereas Crown is more or less the local pimp who is dragging Bess around as his
woman. Robbins wins and Crown refuses to lose and starts a fight and he kills
Robbins, and runs with the money that had been given to him by Bess. Bess
refuses the proposition from Sporting Life to go to New York with him and he goes away too. The scene turns into a dirge dedicated to the
dead man.
Then the people are confronted to the police who want to arrest one man,
no matter who and order the body to be buried by tomorrow or it will be taken
to the medical school to be dissected by the students there. The community has
to collect fifteen dollars to pay for the funeral. The undertaker is there to
collect.
This act shows how this community is poor, cut off from the rest of
society, form the whites, a sort of shared exclusion: the Blacks don’t want to
share anything with the whites and the whites don’t want to have anything to do
with the Blacks. But life is cruel in many ways. The Blacks have anyway
directly or indirectly to work for the whites and every single event in the
Black community may bring the white police in and that means trouble, though
and since the Blacks refuse to tell anything to the police who are obliged to
be blind and arrest the first man they want. And this one is Peter who accuses
Crown, hence breaks the silence law of the Blacks toward the white police.
Porgy, the crippled beggar of the community, refuses to confirm. Peter has
doomed himself for the Blacks: they will not help. He is arrested as a material
witness.
Then the act can proceed to the funeral, led by Bess.
The act so far shows how blocked in their alienation the Blacks are.
Locked up in a closed community that depends on the whites outside for work and
for all types of regulations, the rare businesses they can control are selling
alcohol, selling drugs, providing women, and women are in a dependent state be
they married or not, and undertaker (we will see later various peddlers:
strawberries, crabs, etc.). But they suffer from their alienation to themselves
as a community. Within their community there is a strict order and that order
has to be respected and all Blacks have to be protected against the whites. So Crown
has to be protected since he is Black though the murderer of a Black man, and he is considered as the top or
strong man of the community and as such he has the right to kill if someone
dares to win a crap game against him. The only positive point this opera shows
is that the Blacks are able to sing their fate and dramas in swinging music.
They are born “entertainers,” musicians. They can transform any event into a
musical evocation that is generally collective. They all take part in it, be it
a religious occasion, or a plain everyday life occasion.
This situation is what will be called sixty-five years later or so Post
Traumatic Slavery Syndrome by the Blacks themselves who are trying to get over
this alienated situation that has obviously pushed roots into the Blacks so
deep that these roots have to be pulled out before ever even thinking of
solving other problems. The Gershwins as well as the Heywards could not know
the concept but they definitely are the pioneers of this concept on Broadway.
Note Black authors at the very same time are starting to write about such
situation, Richard Wright for example, but in the same way they are not able
yet to identify the problem. They stay at the level of behaviorism: the
environment of the Blacks produces the behaviors of the Blacks, and this
approach is a progress on the social Darwinism of the end of the 19th
century that considered such behaviors were hereditary: Blacks were born like
that. In the 1920s-1930s they were made like by their social and cultural
environment.
This opera is trying to show that the negative sides are not the only
sides to be considered, but so far we have only been shown the negative sides,
except the solidarity that appears during the funeral since the community
collects the money for the undertaker: the widow cannot pay.
The second act starts with an essential dimension of the Blacks that
gives them some freedom from this behaviorism of theirs. They believe in God,
which is banal, but they project onto themselves the story of Moses taking the
people of Israel out of Egypt and into
the Promised Land. They believe in this Promised Land. The theme had appeared
during the funeral but it could have been seen then as life after death. Now it
is quite different because Jake is hitting the road to go to the Promised Land,
meaning two things. It has to be undertaken by every single individuals. It is
a land that has been promised to any one of them but it is not necessarily the
same land. Each one has to go to his or her promised land. Jake in other words
is going to discover the promised land he is looking for. This gives hope to
the Blacks, but once again this hope is shared by all but has to be reached by
every single individual among them on their own individual initiative, and
within America.
We can think the Gerschwins and the Heywards are answering the idea that was
common in these years under the name of African Nationalism or Black
Nationalism that wanted Black communities to be made entirely autonomous, some
along with Marcus Garvey going as far as asking for a Black state in the USA. One of the
hypothesis was for the USA
to give the Blacks (or for the Blacks to take) what is called the Dust Bowl (The drought and erosion of the Dust
Bowl affected 100,000,000
acres (400,000 km2), centered on the panhandles of Texas and Oklahoma, and adjacent sections of New
Mexico, Colorado, and Kansas.)
The first business exchange is the buying of a divorce for Bess for one
dollar fifty cents from a divorce peddler who pretends to be a lawyer, and
later when a white man from the court comes to get the bail money for Peter
from Porgy, Porgy sends him away telling him things have changed and calling
these “peddlers” nothing but buzzards. Porgy’s consciousness is changing: he
becomes able to step back and look at himself and the situation he is inn
though it confirms the fact that Peter cannot count on support from the Blacks.
But then it is picnic day, a big day of celebration for this Black
community. They go spend the day on an island. Bess does not want to go and
wants to stay with Porgy since Porgy cannot go, I guess because he is a cripple,
but he more or less send Bess to the boat and she goes; The picnic is a day of
liberation and it starts with Sporting Life and some other men making fun of
religion by showing how things are not always what they seem to be or should be
according to the Bible. But the day is to take a bad turn when Bess discovers
Crown is here and the latter forces her to stay with him and to promise she
will go with him when cotton is in. Note the other Black people went on the
boat not even caring for what was happening to Bess and why she was missing.
The shift back to the community’s base finds Bess, one week later, sick
and having been absent two days. She is brought back to consciousness by some
women singing Gospels. She tells Porgy she has been forced to say yes to Crown
but she does not want to go. Porgy then takes over the responsibility and tells
her he will deal with Crown when he comes.
This change in Porgy is extremely interesting. He is the one who is
totally alienated in his social position, since he is a beggar; in his physical
condition since he is a cripple; and in his ethnic position since he is Black.
And it is this threefold-alienated man who only has three things in his life, “Got
my gal, got my Lawd, got my song!” who saves Bess and welcomes and shelters her
when Crown runs away after his crime. He is the one who refuses to say what
happens after the fatal crap game because that’s the rule when dealing with the
whites. And now, little by little he is the one who stands by a woman, her free
will, her right to choose her life and her partner in life. He is the one who
is developing a new sense of responsibility by caring for others and for their
freedom. He is reconstructing a human mind in himself.
It is at this moment the woman, whose husband has got out to sea to fish
comes up with the bad news of a hurricane that hits the community. The
rendering of this storm and the tremendous anxiety for those out at sea is
rendered musically by the second soprano, the tenor, the first soprano, the
alto, the first bass and the second bass singing different solos one on top of
the other, plus some more shorter interventions from other characters. This is
not the best musical idea since then we cannot follow the words of any one of
them. And yet the six solo pieces contain interesting elements to describe the
situation and to define the various references to god. In order these
references are “Doctor Jesus,” “Lawd above,” “Hev’nly Father,” “Professor
Jesus,” “Captain Jesus,” “Father.” It is impossible to enter the richness of
these six visions and the result is nothing but linguistic havoc. That is
supposed to render the violence of the hurricane, but it crushes down the
meaning of the solo parts.
It is in the heart of this hurricane that some knocking is heard at the
door. Crown comes in to take Bess. She refuses, and Porgy tells him to keep
off. At this moment Clara who is fearing for Jake who has gone fishing in the
hurricane asks for some man to help her check if Jake’s boat is back. Only
Crown responds and rushes out. And then the six soloists of the beginning of
the scene sing again their six solos one on top of the other. It is still
impossible to differentiate the words and meanings.
This ending of the second act is very dramatic but extremely ambiguous.
Bess and Porgy are slowly capturing their independence in front of their
community and Crown. But in the danger of this hurricane only Crown was out and
came in and he is also the only one who responded to a call for help. He does
not lack courage and yet he is a murderer who killed for the innings of a crap
game and he is a male chauvinist who refuses to give his woman any freedom: she
is his possession. On the other hand it is quite obvious Porgy cannot compete
since he is a cripple. Maybe he would be courageous if he had the necessary
body.
The third act starts after the storm with a chorus in honor of the
absent men, Jake and Crown. Maria and Sporting Life are considering what was
lost in the hurricane and Bess is taking care of Selena’s baby. Crown comes in
to claim his woman but he is killed by Porgy with a knife in his back twice
while he was trying to crawl on all fours under Porgy’s window. In a way this
end is not very heroic.
The detective and coroner come for some investigation and take Porgy
along as a witness to certify the identity of the victim, Crown. They suspect
Serena, the wife of Crown’s victim, Robbins but can’t prove anything and they
go with Porgy. Then Sporting Life is alone with Bess and he tries to convince
her to come with him to New York
by tempting her with his drugs. It does not seem to work and he leaves. But
Bess comes back for the dope and goes.
The last scene is the return of Porgy after his stint in prison for
contempt of court because he refused to identify Crown. He has presents for a
few people, including a red dress for Bess. But Bess is not there and no one
dares tell him where she is. Finally Maria and Serena tell him the truth. He is
told Bess has left for New York.
So he gets his cart and his goat and leaves. He is on his way to a Heavenly Land.
This ending is surprising since it amplifies the love story between two
people who had nothing in common, but at the same time it makes that love story
impossible. We all know that finding Bess in New York,
or even only Harlem;, will be like finding a
pin in a haystack, if not even worse. This ending is definitely liberating
Porgy from his alienation. He can cut off his mooring and go. He is on his way
to the Promised Land. He has jumped over the obstacle and he is moving again
away from his unbearable situation; All that is the name of love and symbolical
of a real liberation of that Black man.
But Bess is the bad one in that tale. She goes away from the man who had
bought her a divorce, who had killed her ex-husband, who had liberated her from
all enslavement, and yet she falls for some dope, the promise of being a
“woman” in New York,
hence a prostitute in the hands of a pimp and drug dealer.
It is of course, once again a rewriting of Romeo and Juliet, but a
tremendous number of obstacles are piled up in front of them: an age
difference, a social difference, a physical handicap on one side, the fact that
the woman was attached to an authoritarian man, the use of dope and the
practice of prostitution. The worst obstacle is that she cannot live alone one
single minute. And after Porgy’s being taken away and detained by the police she
had to stay alone for a few days. She did not even wait five minutes. And yet
Porgy abandons everything and goes after her. His love is so strong that he can
take the road to New York, no matter how physically challenged he may be, with
no resources, no income, no money, nothing at all, except a goat which is not
going to be very helpful on the road.
The opera sure tells something about the persistence of a Black man when
he is in love: he can fight, kill, serve, find full freedom in this new
dependence. But it also says a lot about the Black woman who is dependent by “nature,”
weak and in great need of protection which is close to possession. She is not
able to see her real interest in love and prefers the evanescent pleasure and
thrill of dope and street walking under the proprietary control of one man.
This is a beautiful story but how does it help the Blacks to step into
their future? It did in 1936 by producing a musical on Broadway that had a
tremendous success and that was showing a nearly entirely Black cast. It also
showed the real triple alienation of a black man like Porgy, the double
alienation of all Black people, the similar double alienation of all Black
women and an alienation that cannot be numbered at all for the Black woman
Bess: she is nothing but a possession and she is the property of the man who
has the strongest and last word. That’s no longer alienation. This is self-fetishization:
Bess transforms herself into a toy in the hands of the latest man who takes
control of her: she is both a sex toy, an economic toy, a social toy, but she
will also be a boxing toy of some type sooner or later, and she will accept it
. . . of course.
This picture of the Black woman is amazing in 1936, not because Black
prostitutes did not exist. They did. But because she is made the central
character of the opera. That’s pathetic and tragic at the same time. She really
sounds like a Black Lulu (composed though not completed in 1935 on the model
written by Frank Wedekind in 1895 and 1904).
Dr Jacques COIULARDEAU
# posted by Dr. Jacques COULARDEAU @ 3:19 PM